For the 1st plague (water turned into blood and the fish died), I found plastic squirting bathtub fish, and everyone got one.
For the 2nd plague (frogs), everyone got a stuffed frog.
For the 3rd plague (insects), everyone got a gummy worm.
For the 4th plague (wild animals), everyone got a toy hippo or lion from the dollar store.
For the 5th plague (livestock disease), everyone got a little toy cow.
For the 6th plague (boils), everyone got a pink bouncy ball.
For the 7th plague (fiery hail), everyone got an orange ball with red streaks.
We didn't have a prop for the 8th (locusts), 9th (darkness) or 10th (death of the first-born) plagues. It was crazy fun, and very yummy, but I'm still exhausted from cooking and cleaning all day. I also decided to take a break from Facebook for Holy Week, so if we're friends on Facebook, that's where I am this week. Have a great Holy Week, and I'll be back on Easter!